Wood burner efficiency FAQ
Legislation and bodies such as HETAS regulate and recommend minimum
efficiencies for solid fuel appliances in the UK and across the
Europe's single market.
|
Minimum efficiency |
Appliance efficiency |
Net % |
Open fire (inset) |
30 |
Freestanding stoves |
65 |
Pellet stoves |
75 |
'Wetback' stoves |
65 |
Masonry heaters |
70 |
The 'CE' legislation requires all stoves sold in the European Union
to declare their tested efficiencies and prohibit the sale of stoves
that fall below these minimums. UK manufacturers have had a exemption
that ends mid 2013. Net and gross efficiencies All figures
quoted by modern manufacturers are net figures. These come in higher
than gross figures, an approximate gross figure can be obtained by
dividing the NET % by 0.9. The difference between net and
gross figures is that net does not not account for the heat
wasted in boiling off the water present in the fuel. It has often
been said that efficiency figures are more a test of the assessors
ingenuity than of the appliance. To be born in mind that how the fuel
is arranged in the firebox can vary the test results but anything up
to 10 per cent. Also the figures ignore heat gained or lost outside of
the appliance, this is especially significant with inset or wetback
stoves. Comparisons to in other areas Despite all the above
criticism of the test figures wood stoves do compare very favourably
with almost all energy intense human activities.
Comparison of approximate
efficiencies in %
|
log boilers |
75 |
wood stove |
73 |
power stations |
40 |
motor vehicles |
25 |
open fires |
25 |
solar panels |
15 |
Comparisons of popular stoves I term appliances with
efficiencies over 80% 'high efficiency' although other retailers will
differ. Clearview were recently defended their position against
an advertising standards complaint that their stoves reach the
"highest environmental standards", by arguing efficiency is only one,
amongst many measures, of the a stoves environmental credentials.
Efficiencies of a variety of
popular stoves in %
(as declared by each manufacturer) |
|
High efficiency stoves |
Xeoos 'Twinfire' |
90+ (claimed) |
Burley
'Debdale' 4kW (World's highest verified) |
89.8 |
Burley
'Hollywell' 5kW |
89.4 |
Broseley 'eVolution'
5kW |
85.5 |
Yeoman 'CL5' 4.9kW |
85 |
Stovax 'View' 4.9kW |
up to 85 |
Stovax 'Stockton' 4kW |
up to 85 |
Heta 'Scan-line 6' 5kW |
84 |
Saltfire ST1 5kW |
83.9 |
Chesney's 'Shoreditch' 4kW |
83.9 |
FDC
freestander '5' 5kW |
82 |
Hotpod unlimited 6kW |
81.6 |
FDC
freestander '5' wide 5kW |
81.5 |
Saltfire ST2 5kW |
81.3 |
AGA 'Little Wenlock' 4.7kW |
81.2 |
Broseley Serrano 3kW |
81 |
Invicta 'Sedan 10' 10kW |
80.8 |
Dovre 'Vintage 30' 5kW |
80.4 |
Mendip 'Loxton' 5kW |
80.3 |
FDC 'inset 5' 5kW |
80 |
Esse '500C' 5kW |
80 |
Medium efficiency stoves |
Chesney's 'Alpine' 6kW |
79.7 |
Bohemia 'X 40 Cube' 4-5kW |
79.5 |
Grey Metal 'Cube' 5kW |
79 |
Firefox '5' 4.9kW |
79 |
Firefox '8' Multi Fuel 8kW |
79 |
Firefox '12' Multi Fuel 12kW |
79 |
Charnwood 'C Four' 4.9kW |
78.3 |
Firefox 5 'CB II' 4.9kW |
78 |
Firebelly 'FB' 5kW |
78 |
Sunrain '10' 7.5kW |
78 |
Grey Metal 'Isis' 10kW |
77 |
Tiger 6kW |
77 |
Carron 'Dante' 5kW |
76.9 |
AGA 'Ludlow' 6.5kW |
76.2 |
Morso 'Squirrel (1410 & 1430)'
4.6kW |
76 |
Villager 'Heron' 5kW |
76 |
Aarrow 'Ecoburn' 5kW |
74.7 |
Bullerjan '02' 15kW |
74 |
Grey Metal 'Nero' 5kW |
73.5 |
Clarke (Machine Mart) 'Majestic'
13.2kW |
73.5 |
Carron '5' 5kW |
72 |
Clearview 'Pioneer 400' 5kW |
71.9 |
Aarrow 'Acorn' 5kW |
70.58 |
Relatively low efficiency stoves |
Clarke (Machine Mart) 'Barrel'
11.8kW |
68 |
Few appliances come in below 70% these days, although there are
often other advantages to 'low efficiency' stoves such as longevity,
ease of lighting and purchase price. Many modern stoves achieve
their high efficiencies with the use of firebricks to line the
firebox, these bricks have a finite life and will probably require
replacing every few years. |